Page 1 of 1
Hypothetical Tricky Question
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 12:57 am
by TractorRob
With much talk about Dyer wanting to return to us, i was just wondering how youd fell about this situation...
Souness, annoyed by Dyer's constant misbehaviour and dissilloisanment that he is a gangsta who grew up in Compton he decides to offload the little guy on loan till the end of the season to avoid any more unrest and disruption in the dressing room after which he will sell him.
Considering he has electric pace(something we lack) and can rip most Premiership defences to pieces (well, a couple) let alone Championship ones. Would you or would you not want him until the end of the season?
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 1:09 am
by Phil
he wouldn't come back. and his wage demands would be way to high.
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 1:42 am
by crazee
he only wants to come back to us when he's in his twilight years, so lets see about 8 years
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 12:02 pm
by TractorRob
Phil wrote:he wouldn't come back. and his wage demands would be way to high.
Thats why its a hypothetical question, i wasnt actually suggesting he would come i was just wondering what peoples opinions would be IF he did.
Re: Hypothetical Tricky Question
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 12:43 pm
by Mork
TractorRob88 wrote:With much talk about Dyer wanting to return to us, i was just wondering how youd fell about this situation...
Souness, annoyed by Dyer's constant misbehaviour and dissilloisanment that he is a gangsta who grew up in Compton he decides to offload the little guy on loan till the end of the season to avoid any more unrest and disruption in the dressing room after which he will sell him.
Considering he has electric pace(something we lack) and can rip most Premiership defences to pieces (well, a couple) let alone Championship ones. Would you or would you not want him until the end of the season?
If you believe the stories, Dyer has been the biggest problem at Newcastle for several seasons. He was leading the Bellamy brigade in the dressing room, and undermined Bobby Robson, up to the point where Robson had lost all credibility.
He's clearly an utterly arrogant pr*ck outside of the game, so I have to ask why on earth anyone would vote yes on this - clearly another case of people putting winning above everything else. I guess these same people would be like the Birmingham fans who gave Jermaine Pennant a standing ovation on his return? (I felt sick). Wonder if they'd have done that had his drunken idiocy resulted in a few dead kids on the side of the road?
Dyer is the kind of influence who can dismantle and destroy a team, much as he is doing to Newcastle - why on earth would we want him here?
(My argument can be further strengthened by the fact he's not even that bloody good - totally over-rated, and only puts in 1/10 stella performances).
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 1:28 pm
by crikes
would not want to see him back
we do not need that individual attitude in the dressing room. we are currently a team with great team spirit with no individuals so why change it
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 4:19 pm
by Gaz
Not a chance in hell

Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 6:57 pm
by Dazza
I personally would love to see an England international back in our side.
Re: Hypothetical Tricky Question
Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2005 11:53 pm
by mr logic
TractorRob88 wrote:With much talk about Dyer wanting to return to us, i was just wondering how youd fell about this situation...
Souness, annoyed by Dyer's constant misbehaviour anddissilloisanment that he is a gangsta who grew up in Compton he decides to offload the little guy on loan till the end of the season to avoid any more unrest and disruption in the dressing room after which he will sell him.
Considering he has electric pace(something we lack) and can rip most Premiership defences to pieces (well, a couple) let alone Championship ones. Would you or would you not want him until the end of the season?

WTF does that mean.
He`s trouble with a capital T, always has been always will be.
Posted: Tue Apr 05, 2005 12:06 am
by Jonno
NO WAY, even if we were desperate i wouldnt take that jumped up little sh*t back
Posted: Wed Apr 06, 2005 12:34 pm
by airliner
I have heard some particularly bad stories about what he gets up to in his private life,not a good person really.We need players who are professional in all aspects of their life and those who die to play for their club;such as some of the young players coming through the reserves and academy.Its never the same when they come back again;Scowcroft for one.We could not afford him either.Why not go for Leroy lita of bristol fame.
Re: Hypothetical Tricky Question
Posted: Wed Apr 06, 2005 1:41 pm
by TractorRob
mr logic wrote:TractorRob88 wrote:With much talk about Dyer wanting to return to us, i was just wondering how youd fell about this situation...
Souness, annoyed by Dyer's constant misbehaviour anddissilloisanment that he is a gangsta who grew up in Compton he decides to offload the little guy on loan till the end of the season to avoid any more unrest and disruption in the dressing room after which he will sell him.
Considering he has electric pace(something we lack) and can rip most Premiership defences to pieces (well, a couple) let alone Championship ones. Would you or would you not want him until the end of the season?

WTF does that mean.
He`s trouble with a capital T, always has been always will be.
I would have thought sum1 who calls themself 'Mr Logic' would know that dissillusionment (may have spelt it wrong at first) means thinking you are something that you are not.