Well I just couldn't resist the temptation to chip in. I'll be honest I really find it hard to criticise MM in general. Obviously we all have our favourites and players that we would prefer not to see pulling on the shirt but honestly on our budgets MM does a fantastic job. Let's just remind ourselves that 'our budgets' means that we are paying transfer fees and salaries to players that match the better of the bottom half (financially) of the teams in our division. This year we will finish in the bottom half and that's about what you might expect with our resources.
MM has done his best to collect together a decent squad of players (by bottom half standards) and perhaps hasn't got any more out of them than average this season. In previous seasons he has done much better. Why is this season different? Hard to say, maybe after a few years of finding ways to motivate average players to give a bit extra it becomes hard to repeat the trick and a clearout and freshen up is required. MM seems to have implied this with recent comments. In my personal opinion we play very well as a team unit and are hard to break down. This is about the best we can hope for without the quality of players that even our local rivals have at their disposal. Maybe there is a secret formula or formation that can surprise everyone and work miracles but I doubt it.
Timing of his comments isn't a great mystery, he was asked the question (unsurprisingly) and gave an honest answer and one which I greatly respect. As an employer myself I would expect my contractors and staff to work out their contracts and would be very unhappy to hear that they were thinking (out loud in the press!) about whether or not they were going to deign to honour the contract that they had signed. I would be equally unhappy knowing that even 12 months before the end of their contract they have no clue about how they are going to go about their job. Stop the conspiracy theories guys, Micks an straightforward guy, we at least all know that.
I appreciate that I don't pay any of my hard earned cash to go to games and even this forum is thankfully free, and that some of you spend thousands every season on this passion that we all share but I think a reality check might be needed. In my opinion nothing will be different next season, but there is reason to be optimistic about it nonetheless:
a. We have discovered a new formation this season 5-3-2 which has the promise to produce exciting football. At present we have two young wing backs who are making it work. They still look a bit raw and maybe naive defensively but they have the energy and pace required to bomb up and down the wings, young Kenlock is starting to rack up a number of assists as testament to that. They will get improve. In the centre we have players who will also improve into the system (as Knudsen has improved into the left CB position) and Chambers gets to play in the centre at last. Maybe we are looking for another right CB?
b. Diagouraga is looking like a good attack minded alternative to Cole Skuse. Will we try and sign him in the Summer? Might not be a bad call, or maybe there are others out there like him? Skuse is getting older and maybe he will be kept only for ultra defensive setups next season.
c. Huws looks like the best forward thinking midfielder that we have had for some time (not counting players who spend long spells injured). Will we try to sign him? We will see.
d. Grant Ward is starting to look like the player that we all hoped he would be and is maybe benefitting from regular starts.
For me the recovery of Bishop & Hyam is pretty irrelevant. The quality improvement in the Champ makes them squad players at best.
The biggest problem is who to replace Tom Lawrence with and we will probably have to make do with another Prem player that won't be identified until the season is under way - that's life for us I'm afraid.
Also maybe it's time for a change of personnel up front. We definitely need a 'bruiser' up top since all of our forwards are lightweight. Someone to give a physical presence. Murphy was clearly just as good as we all thought and is scoring regularly at Newcastle too. We never did replace him and that's the challenge, unfortunately we won't be able to afford a known player and will have to rely on TC to bring through someone from the lower leagues which will not happen overnight.
To finish, I think that MMs work at present is highly under appreciated. I don't give a t*ss about his sideswipes at fans since sometimes IMO they deserve them. With Mick you have to take the rough with the smooth. If ME decides to listen to the fans and bring in a new young manager with a mandate to play entertaining, attacking football, but continues to invest in the same way as he does now then prepare for League 1 footy in 2018-19